Methodology

Measured by machines. Judged by people.

Automated technical assessment and human jury evaluation are kept strictly separate, then combined using a weighting the awards team publishes for each year.

Automated assessment

Website Assessment Engine

Every eligible entry with a reachable public URL is analysed against measurable quality indicators. Results are stored with the submission and shown to judges as context — never as a substitute for their own evaluation.

  • Availability and response behaviour
  • Page performance indicators
  • Mobile responsiveness signals
  • Accessibility indicators
  • SEO fundamentals
  • Technology detection
  • Basic security posture signals

Weighting: Set per award year

Human judging

Independent jury evaluation

Judges see only the submissions assigned to them. They inspect the live website and supporting materials, score each criterion on the configured scale and may leave confidential comments. Once submitted, an evaluation is locked unless an authorised administrator reopens it.

Weighting: Set per award year

Criteria & weights

Published scoring criteria.

Design

Visual craft, brand expression and compositional quality.

UX / UI

Navigation clarity, interaction quality and task completion.

Performance

Loading behaviour, responsiveness and delivery speed.

Mobile Experience

Adaptation, touch ergonomics and small-screen hierarchy.

Accessibility

Inclusive practice, contrast, semantics and assistive support.

Content

Editorial quality, structure, tone and information value.

Technical Excellence

Engineering quality, stability, security and SEO fundamentals.

Innovation

Original thinking that advances the craft of the web.

Round mechanics

How a judging round runs.

01

Safety screening

Every submitted URL is screened automatically. Dangerous links are blocked outright and suspicious ones are held for manual review.

02

Eligibility and release

The awards team checks the entry against the published rules, then releases it to the jury. Nothing reaches a judge before that release.

03

Open panel scoring

There are no per-judge assignments. Every appointed judge may score every released entry within the round window.

04

Round closure

When the programme manager closes the round, scoring locks. Late or incomplete evaluations are not counted.

05

Publication

Combined scores are calculated, reviewed and published. Entries reaching 80 or above appear as Featured Websites; the rest stay private.

Conflict of interest

Judges declare any relationship with an entrant, agency or brand. A declared conflict removes that judge's score from the entry.

Confidential comments

Judge comments are recorded for the awards team and shared with entrants as feedback, never attributed to an individual judge.

Score integrity

Entrants cannot view or edit scores. Only the programme manager can correct a recorded score, and every change is logged.